Despite a dominating performance, the Bulldogs (8-5-1 overall, 6-1-1 AAC) fell out of a first-place tie with a double-overtime 1-1 tie against the fourth-place Skyhawks (6-8-1, 3-3-1).
Bryan leads the conference with a 7-1 mark.
The Bulldogs held a 34-7 advantage in shots; 13-3 edge in shots on goal and were 10-0 on corner kicks earned, but needed a goal from Ryan Ejezie, assisted by Ross Nelson, with less than nine minutes remaining to force the two overtime sessions, which were scoreless.
Keeper Clark Lydon collected two saves.
The Bulldogs host Union College on Saturday at 3:15 pm and will honor Senior members of the team.